Perhaps it's the fact that I turned 40 this year, or that my job was busier than ever, or that playing with my kids takes up a lot of the time I used to devote to music. Whatever the case, I found my tolerance for challenging music that required multiple listens before I would "get it" was limited. At the same time, I probably listened to more albums all the way through than I have in years. It was a case of constantly seeking out the new thing and being disappointed. So many bands were hyped this year (which is, of course, nothing new) that were good but nowhere near as great as promised. Woods, Dan Deacon, Fuck Buttons, Memory Tapes, Real Estate... the list goes on and on. I liked something on all of these, but none were anywhere near the best thing I've heard all year.

I found that what it came down to, the thing that put something on this list more than anything else, is that I enjoyed listening to it. Now, that may seem obvious, but any look at a usual end-of-the-year list proves that it is far from it. People often populate their lists with challenging music, either because they want to impress readers, or because they truly spent the time to figure out what was going on and want a pat on the back. I have certainly been guilty of that in the past.

Not this year. In 2009, if you didn't captivate me right out of the gate, you were tossed on the one-and-done pile. That's not to say there isn't challenging fare on the following list, but rather that even the most perplexing albums at least had something that immediately grabbed me and made subsequent spins seem worthwhile.

With that, I present the Things I'd Rather Be Doing list of the best music of 2009. Following is a short list of great reissues and collections.

1. Deer Tick - Born on Flag Day - If fun and enjoyment are the bellwether's of a great disc, then Deer Tick wins hands down. Born on Flag Day is the most rousing, irreverent goodtimin' disc I've heard in a long time. John J. McCauley III succeeds despite the fact that his reach does not exceed his grasp; one feels like he has much better stuff in him, but what he's doing now is still awfully good. Live, the band puts on the most entertaining show I've seen in years, and you can just tell that as good as songs like "Easy" and "Smith Hill" are, this is only the beginning.

2. Neko Case - Middle Cyclone - Neko Case has such an identifiable sound that one fears she'll run out of ways to excel. No such worries yet, however. Middle Cyclone may well be her best album (and that's saying something), because it finds ways to push her sound forward while making it clear that we're still listening to Neko Case. Her songwriting, a pleasant surprise on Fox Confessor Brings the Flood, is in full bloom here, proving Case to be a formidable multi-talented performer.

3. Fever Ray - s/t - I never really saw the appeal of the Knife, the band of Fever Ray's Karin Dreijer Andersson, but for some reason her similar solo work smacked me upside the head and forced me to listen. Where Silent Shout seemed unremittingly cold, the Fever Ray disc used that icy tone as simply one of many tools. The songs seemed more fully formed, and despite the chill, they were still a pleasure to listen to. Andersson's gimmick of altering the pitch of her voice to add menace to the proceedings, deployed on the Knife's music, worked even better here. The most revelatory thing I heard all year.

4. Flaming Lips - Embryonic - The F'lips last, At War with the Mystics, was awful, one of the worst albums from a beloved band I've ever heard. I had hoped Wayne Coyne and Co. would retreat somewhat, but never expected they would regress so far. Had this album come after the majesty of Zaireeka, no one would have been surprised. That this swirling cloud of cacophony and blissed-out beauty followed the band's first true dud was the most pleasant surprise of 2009. There were no real singles, and it essentially stopped the band's commercial momentum in its tracks. But it proved that the band has much more up its sleeve, and makes the future seem very bright indeed.

5. Grizzly Bear - Vekatemist - The Grizzly Bear backlash has begun, and it is not without merit. The band, while making gorgeous music, does so in a largely soulless, rather mechanical way. Vekatemist has its share of absolutely stunning music ("Two Weeks" is among the five best songs of the year without question), but it is music made seemingly without passion. That missing ingredient kept this disc away from the upper reaches of this list. Here's hoping they find it in years to come.

6. The Pains of Being Pure at Heart - s/t - Ah, sweet nostalgia. Had this been issued in the late 1980s on Sarah Records or K, it would be seen as a classic of the college rock era. Instead, it comes 20 years later, proving that at least someone who was listening to their big brother's record collection was absorbing the lessons on display. This is a fun, raucous disc that sounds a bit like Belle and Sebastian had that band been formed in a garage instead of a college rec room.

7. St. Vincent - Actor - Annie Clark is a wildly talented woman: a singer, songwriter and guitarist who puts all of those skills to work on her sophomore outing to create a bracing rock album. It's hard to point out any one thing and say, "this is St. Vincent." Instead, Clark has (not so) simply assembled a disc of great songs that make the best use of her strengths.

8. Nirvana - Live at Reading - Truth told, this may be the best album of the year. It's hard to award a nearly 20-year-old live album from a band that stopped making music more than 15 years ago the title of album of the year, however, so instead it sits here in the bottom of the top 10. There's little that can be said that hasn't been said before. This is one of the best bands of its generation playing its strongest songs in a take-no-prisoners performance before a powerful, adoring crowd.

9. DJ Spooky - The Secret Song - When I first popped this in, I was intrigued. As it continued to play, I was continually blindsided. Is that a cover of Led Zeppelin's "Dazed and Confused"? At times this sounds like the great lost Beastie Boys album, at others it rivals the best of DJ Shadow or the Jurassic 5 or Springheel Jack. Translation: this is a little something of everything. By the end of its 20 tracks, you feel spent, but it isn't long before the desire to cue this up again takes over. That's a good thing, because it'll take several spins before it all sinks in.

10. U2 - No Line on the Horizon - This pick will surely earn me some catcalls, but hear me out. "Get On Your Boots" is a fairly awful retread. "I'll Go Crazy if I Don't Go Crazy Tonight" is Bono the old man trying so hard to connect with the kids and failing so miserably. "Unknown Caller"'s lyrics peppered with computer terminology are inane. That would be enough to sink most albums, but not this one, for the rest of it is as accomplished and flat out stunning as anything U2 has made since Achtung, Baby 20 years ago. "Magnificent" is the kind of anthem you wished the band had cranked out instead of by-the-numbers tunes like "Vertigo" and "Beautiful Day," while the title track is a perfect blend of the band's pomp and producer Brian Eno's circumstance. And for the band to be able to craft something as beautiful as "What as Snow" at this point is remarkable.

11. Love Language - s/t
12. Yo La Tengo - Popular Songs
13. The xx - s/t
14. Joe Henry - Blood from Stars
15. Bonnie Prince Billy - Beware
16. Gomez - A New Tide
17. John Wesley Harding - Who Was Changed and Who Was Dead
18. Ike Reilly - Hardluck Stories
19. The Dead Weather - Horehound
20. Boston Spaceships - The Planets are Blasted


Reissues/Collections

Nick Lowe - Quiet Please
Emitt Rhodes - The Emitt Rhodes Recordings 1969-1973
Tin Huey - Before Obscurity
The Jayhawks - Music from the North Country
Big Star - Keep an Eye on the Sky
Richard Hell - Destiny Street Repaired
Close Lobsters - Forever Until Victory

Labels: lists, music